Portraits – a pencil drawing v photos

Pencil portrait of two smiling women

Why would anyone pay for a pencil drawing when a phone takes a perfect photo in a second? As someone who draws portraits for a living, I have thought about it a lot. Here is my honest answer on a pencil drawing v photos, and when each one is the better choice.

What a photo does best

A photo is quick, accurate and almost free. Most of us carry a very good camera in our pocket, and it can capture a moment in a fraction of a second. For recording an event, a likeness or a place, a photo is hard to beat. Photos are also better at showing a whole scene. A beach, a wedding venue or a busy family gathering is often best left as a photo.

But a photo records everything equally. The stray lead, the cluttered background, the red eye from the flash and the odd shadow across a cheek all get the same attention as the face you actually care about.

What a drawing can do that a photo cannot

When I draw, I choose. I keep everything that makes a person or animal recognisable, and I can leave out what does not belong. When I am drawing a dog portrait and the ears happened to droop in the photo, I can draw them pricked and alert, the way the owner knows them. If a grandparent’s glasses caught the light, I can draw their eyes as you remember them.

There is also something of the artist in every drawing. Each pencil mark is a decision, and that is why a drawing can feel warmer than the photo it came from. People often tell me they notice things in a portrait that they had never seen in the original picture. I can also bring out texture that a camera tends to flatten, like the softness of a cat’s fur or the lines around a smile.

When a drawing makes more sense

A pencil portrait earns its place when the picture will be looked at for years: a memorial for a much-loved pet, an anniversary gift, or a family portrait for the hallway. It also helps when the only photos you have are old or taken on an early phone, because I can work from the clearest parts of each one. A drawing also ages well. A pencil portrait in a good frame looks as fresh in twenty years as it does on the day it arrives.

A photo is still the better choice when you need something quickly or cheaply, or when you want lots of copies. My portraits take around a fortnight and start at £70, so they suit the occasions that matter most.

Getting the best of both

In practice, the two work together. Every portrait I draw starts with your photos, so the better the photo, the better the drawing. Take it in daylight, at eye level, with the face in focus. You can read more about how I work in pencil portraits from photos, or look through the pet and people portraits I have drawn.

Plenty of people have argued that painting represents mankind better than photography, and I would say the same about pencil. If you would like a portrait that captures more than a photo can, you can order a pencil portrait online.

Browse by topic
Pets
1
People
1
Gifts
5
Tips
3
Commission a portrait
Pencil portrait of two French bulldogs

Your photo, drawn by hand

Sizes A5 to A1, framed or unframed. From £70.

Commission a portrait

Turn your favourite photo into a hand drawn portrait

Choose your size and frame, upload your photos and order online. Prices from £70.